Why I Never Argue With Someone When They Break Up With Me

Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on pinterest
Share on email

Okay, here’s the deal. If someone wants to break up with me, I say “okay.” I accept it. I might ask why if I’m curious. But I don’t argue with them about it.


Well, here’s the way I see it. When someone decides they want to break up with me, there are two possibilities:

  1. They have a good reason.
  2. They don’t have a good reason.

Scenario #1: They Have a Good Reason

Obviously, if they have a good reason to break up with me, then they should do it. I do the best I’m capable of in relationships. If that isn’t a good fit for someone — for whatever reason — then it isn’t a good fit. Arguing with them isn’t going to change something that’s a true dealbreaker for them, a good reason for them to be breaking up with me. It’s just wasted energy.

Scenario #2: They Don’t Have a Good Reason

“Okay, Page,” you might be saying, “but what if they don’t have a good reason. What if they’re about to throw away a perfectly good relationship for a silly reason?”

Here’s the thing: I don’t want to date someone like that. Someone who will discard another person on a whim for what’s not a good reason.

Is it possible that there’s some kind of misunderstanding and I could possibly talk to them and resolve it and finagle my way back into their good graces? Yes, quite possibly.

But do I really want to commit more time and energy to a person who pushes the “breakup” button so easily? Do I want to leave myself emotionally vulnerable to someone who pursues the breakup option lightly — and hopes the other person will talk them out of it “if they really care”?

No. I don’t.

And for what it’s worth, it’s probably best to know this as soon as possible.

Every Time I Deviate from this Pattern, I End Up Sorry

It might sound a little oversimplified. And you might be sitting there thinking up all sorts of edge cases and times when this strategy of mine could be a BIG FREAKING MISTAKE… but to be honest, I’ve tried deviating from it. (In one case, I had second thoughts and reached out later. In another, I was humoring the response of a third party, who was dating this person at the same time I was.) And every single time I deviate from this pattern, I’m sorry.


Featured Image: CC 0 – Pixabay